New Homes & Taxes

April 15^th always reminds me of taxes, and how high our taxes are here. Is this a disadvantage when it comes to selling homes in this area?

I always counsel my new clients relocating here from other states that property taxes are something that need to be viewed as part of an entire budget. Yes, our property taxes seem much higher than in many other regions of this country, and yes, upon first look, it can be a deterrent. But my advice to out-of-towners is to consider how much they pay each year in all forms of tax.

In Pennsylvania, we only pay a 3.08% income tax rate and here in Sewickley, we add on top of that an additional 1% on earned income only. We currently have no sales tax on food and clothing. We also have very low car registration fees at only $36/car. In some states, income tax alone can be as much as 8% – 9%, car registration fees/yearly taxes can exceed $550+/car and they do impose sales tax on food and clothing. If buyers are counseled to look at the big picture, more often than not they find that they are actually saving money when they move to Western PA, despite our high property taxes, but it does take a skilled realtor to get them over this hump.

When dealing with local buyers, property taxes are a much bigger issue. When moving up, buyers definitely have to consider taxes – they won’t be getting any new income tax breaks by just moving across town. Recently, the federal tax law changed and there is a $10,000 cap on the deductibility of the combined total of income and property taxes.  Nationwide, this seems to have created a softening in the sale of high-end homes as there is little to no subsidy for your property taxes anymore (depending on how much you pay in state and local income taxes and whether they, on their own, move you above the $10,000 threshold).  The expectation is that the lower federal tax rates will offset the reduced deduction, but for many who haven’t filed their 2018 returns yet, it’s too early to tell. My sense is that this will all settle out over the next year or two as we all adjust to the new tax rules.

In any event, whether buying or selling, it’s important to take the time to make sure that your taxes are in line with the market value of your home – if they are not you should appeal them so that inappropriately high taxes don’t become an even larger deterrent to a purchaser.